top of page

How Shopping Around Can Lower Your Home Insurance Costs

2 days ago
6 min read

Home insurance premiums have become a bigger part of the monthly cost of owning a home. For many buyers and homeowners, the bill can feel fixed, almost like property taxes or a mortgage payment. But it is not always as set in stone as it seems.


Insurance pricing can vary widely from one provider to another. The same home, owner, and coverage needs may produce different quotes depending on the company’s risk models, discounts, underwriting rules, and appetite for certain markets.


That means one of the simplest ways to manage your housing costs is also one of the most often overlooked: compare your options before you choose a policy, and keep comparing when renewal time comes around.


Shopping around can pay off


Many homeowners have more control over insurance costs than they realize. According to Intercontinental Exchange, homeowners who switched insurance providers after shopping around saw their premiums drop by an average of 6.6%.


By contrast, homeowners who stayed with their existing providers saw premiums increase by 10.4%.


That difference can add up quickly. Intercontinental Exchange found that homeowners who switched saved an average of about $440 per year.




That is real money, especially when homeowners are already managing mortgage payments, property taxes, utilities, maintenance, and repairs. A few hundred dollars a year could help cover part of an emergency fund, a home repair, or a higher utility bill during peak seasons.


The most useful part of the finding is that the savings did not appear to come from simply cutting back protection. According to the same data, homeowners who switched saw their deductibles decrease by 1.4%, while their coverage limits increased by 7.3%.


In plain terms, some homeowners paid less while also getting more favorable policy terms.


That will not happen in every case, of course. Insurance rates depend on many factors, including location, home condition, claims history, credit-based insurance scores where allowed, and the level of coverage selected. But the data makes one thing clear: staying with the same provider year after year can be convenient, but it does not always lead to the best price.


Why insurance quotes can vary so much


Home insurance companies do not all price risk the same way. One company may place more weight on the age of the home. Another may focus more on roof condition, wildfire risk, wind exposure, claim trends, or local rebuilding costs.


That is why two providers can look at the same property and offer different premiums.


A few common factors that can affect your quote include:


  • The home’s age and condition Older homes may have aging roofs, plumbing, electrical systems, or materials that cost more to repair.


  • Location risks Homes in areas with higher exposure to storms, fires, flooding, or theft may cost more to insure.


  • Replacement cost The cost to rebuild the home, not just its market value, plays a major role in coverage needs.


  • Deductible amount A higher deductible often lowers the premium, but it also means paying more out of pocket after a claim.


  • Claims history Past claims by the homeowner or claims tied to the property can affect pricing.


  • Available discounts Bundling home and auto insurance, installing security features, or adding certain protective systems may reduce costs.


Because each insurer weighs these factors differently, one company’s expensive quote may not reflect the whole market. It may simply mean that provider is not the best fit for that particular home or homeowner.


First-time buyers should compare before closing


For first-time buyers, home insurance can come as a surprise. It is often discussed late in the process, after the offer is accepted and the lender is asking for proof of coverage.


That timing can make it tempting to grab the first quote that arrives.


But rushing can cost you. Home insurance is part of the total monthly housing budget, and it can affect affordability in a meaningful way. Before choosing a policy, first-time buyers should compare quotes from multiple providers and make sure each quote is based on similar coverage.


When comparing policies, look beyond the premium. Pay attention to:


  • Dwelling coverage

  • Personal property coverage

  • Liability protection

  • Loss of use coverage

  • Deductibles

  • Exclusions

  • Wind, hail, flood, or earthquake limits where relevant


A cheaper policy is not always better if it leaves major gaps. The goal is to find strong coverage at a fair price, not just the lowest number on the page.


This is also a good time to ask questions. A trusted insurance professional can explain what is included, what is excluded, and what coverage levels may fit the home. A real estate professional can also help flag property features that may affect insurance costs, such as an older roof, outdated systems, or location-specific risks.


Reviewing your policy each year matters


Shopping around is not only for new buyers. Current homeowners can benefit from reviewing their coverage every year when the policy comes up for renewal.


Renewal notices are easy to overlook. Many homeowners receive the documents, see that coverage continues, and move on. But a renewal is a good checkpoint.


Before renewing, review:


  • The new premium

  • Any changes to deductibles

  • Coverage limits

  • New exclusions or endorsements

  • Discounts that may be missing

  • Whether your home value or rebuilding cost has changed


If your premium increased, ask your provider why. Sometimes the reason is tied to broader market conditions, rising repair costs, or regional claim activity. Other times, your policy may need to be updated based on changes to the home.


Even if your current provider has served you well, getting outside quotes can give you a better sense of whether the renewal price is still competitive.


You are not locked into your first offer. You are also not required to stay with the same insurance company forever. If another provider offers comparable or better protection at a lower cost, switching may be worth considering.


The home you choose can affect your premium


Insurance costs are not only about the provider. The home itself plays a major role.


According to John Burns Research and Consulting, newly built homes are generally 10% to 15% less expensive to insure than older homes nationally.


That makes sense. Newer homes often include updated electrical systems, plumbing, roofing, building materials, and safety features. They may also meet newer building codes, which can reduce certain risks from an insurer’s point of view.


A new construction home will not be the right fit for every buyer. Price, location, lot size, neighborhood character, commute, and personal preferences all matter. But insurance costs should be part of the comparison when weighing a newer home against an older one.


For example, an older home may have charm, mature landscaping, and a desirable location. But if it needs a roof replacement, has outdated wiring, or uses older plumbing, the insurance premium may be higher. In some cases, the insurer may require repairs before issuing or renewing coverage.


A newer home may cost more upfront, but lower insurance costs could help offset part of the monthly budget. The only way to know is to compare the full picture, not just the purchase price.


A lower premium should not mean weaker coverage


Saving money is helpful, but home insurance is there to protect against major financial loss. Cutting coverage too far can create bigger problems later.


When comparing policies, make sure each quote uses the same or similar assumptions. Otherwise, the comparison may be misleading.


For example, one quote may look lower because it includes:


  • A much higher deductible

  • Lower dwelling coverage

  • Less personal property protection

  • Limited roof coverage

  • Fewer endorsements

  • Exclusions for risks that matter in your area


Ask each provider to explain how the policy would respond after a major claim. If a storm damages the roof, what is covered? If the home becomes temporarily unlivable, what expenses are included? If rebuilding costs rise, does the policy include extra protection?


The best result is not just a lower payment. It is a policy that fits the home, protects against the right risks, and makes sense within the household budget.


The bottom line


Home insurance has become a larger part of the cost of homeownership, but homeowners are not powerless. Shopping around can lower your home insurance costs, especially when you compare policies carefully instead of accepting the first quote or automatically renewing.


Start by getting quotes from multiple providers. Review your coverage every year. Look closely at deductibles, limits, and exclusions. If you are buying a home, factor the property’s age, condition, and construction type into your budget.


A trusted real estate professional and a knowledgeable insurance agent can help you ask better questions before you commit. The right policy should protect the home, fit the budget, and give you confidence that you are not paying more than you need to.


Comments


2603 Camino Ramon, Suite 200, San Ramon, CA 94583

eXp Realty of California, Inc.

CA DRE# 01878277 

  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • facebook
  • youtube

(C) 2025 "Will & Way Homes"

bottom of page